Cancel Kids Take On Blogger

I have received a number of emails about my last post from the students campaigning to have two Skidmore faculty members fired.

They were quite upset and indignant that I had not redacted all their names and monikers from the Instagram postings I published.

Apparently when you publish something on Instagram, the name of the individual posting (or their on-line moniker) appears in the upper left of their document.

I had overlooked the actual name of one of the authors of two posts. As a courtesy I redacted that person’s name.

In the other cases where those complaining had posted using aliases I made no changes.

The persons making these demands emailed me through the WordPress web program I use. I would not characterize the emails I have received as a charm campaign. One of them advised me that he would be consulting a lawyer regarding the matter.

All of them asserted that I was violating their privacy and that I was putting them in danger. The implication being I guess that someone from the right might be motivated to hurt them.

It seems odd to me that they should be so insistent on anonymity. The documents I published that included their names or their aliases are already on the web and available to anyone with a computer. I do not see myself as “outing” them. In the case of actual names, I redacted as a courtesy because I was hoping that on reflection they might reconsider the wisdom of both the purpose of their campaign (the firing of faculty based on simply attending a rally) and the manner by which they are running their campaign (it includes information that is demonstrably untrue).

There are a number of things striking about their emails to me. The first is the presumption that they can order me to remove their names.

Given the tone of their Instagram posts, I would have thought that they would be proud to have their names associated with their remarks. I am also surprised at their claim that having their names or monikers appear on the blog is suddenly a cause for fear. After all, they have already put their names out on the web in spite of the fact that they apparently believe that publicly taking on what they see as the alt-right may put them in danger. I am unclear why my posting should significantly increase the risk, if any, that they have already willingly taken on.

Ironically they have not been reluctant to post the names and pictures of their faculty targets. They attempted to get the faculty members’ names up on my blog by emailing them in a comment they wanted posted (I didn’t). They have broadcast where their targets work, and most importantly, they have contacted the employer of their targets and asked that the two be fired. They seem oblivious to the contradictions between their demands for privacy and safety for themselves and the real dangers they are willing to create for others.

Rethinking What All This Is About

It is disturbing how many of the letters and documents created and passed along on social media by these students contained allegations that are demonstrably untrue. In the private correspondence I received, one writer admitted that neither she nor the author of the original letter were ever students in the department of the the faculty members they were condemning nor had they taken any of their classes. Another student admitted that they were not at the July 30 protest but had passed on information about what happened that night. That information simply wasn’t true.

I am struggling to understand the behavior of these students. My impression is that they truly believe that events they describe actually occurred even though the allegations they make are demonstrably untrue. They seem to be untethered to reality.

What makes them construct these fantasies and pass them on? Is it the quest for celebrity status by being on the front lines of something exciting that is happening? Is it an attempt to exercise some sense of power and control in an increasingly hostile world by constructing one’s own reality?

Sadly it is not just students who exhibit this behavior, though. Their actions appear to be part of a disturbing national trend and not exclusive to any political party, age group, or social class .

It is unproductive to simply denounce these people, and I really do not have any easy answers as to why all of this is happening or how to change this behavior.

My personal response to this trend is to publish this blog. This blog tries to make sense out of events and create a space where people can comfortably and intelligently consider local issues.

As those who follow this blog know, it can be sharply critical of people and institutions but it is not mean spirited. People who have posted comments on this site using real email addresses, using language that is too strong, are accustomed to hearing from me with a request that they edit their submission and “dial it back.”

My hope is to create some space, however small, for honest and civil conversations.

6 thoughts on “Cancel Kids Take On Blogger”

  1. Once again I have been thwarted by WordPress to post my comment. Here it is, do as you please.

    Our culture seems to have nurtured a class of shallowly commited rebels that see that social media , often promoted by the executive branch, promotes and makes them believe that they can spew venom, yet they cower when the responsibilty of such boomerangs in their laps. If one has a strong belief, and can’t stand the heat when their theory is tested, then they have no strong belief. Go home whimpering child.

    Like

  2. Any word on how the college has reacted to the cancel kids and their demands to these targeted instructors? That would be the best barometer of whether we have a bigger problems than some misguided youths…. academia seems to have been part of why these kids have lost their way.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Those emails reflect the education they received at Skidmore. Skidmore is not unique in its challenges. For example, the University at Albany Rockefeller Homeland Security program educates foreign students on our continuity of government. Higher education has become an industry just like everything else, and those students are the product. The Country is having an identity crisis. If you swing too far to a national identity, you get called a Nazi, if you swing to an ethnic identity, you are a racist. People are scared to believe in something because you get crucified by the digital mob for expression outside of a constructed mainstream.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Colleges are suppose to train you to think, not what to think. So much for debating topics and shaking hands at the end. (Alright however you’re allowed do a handshake with social distancing…)

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Self-entitled College kids who have never worked a day in their life are in no position, personally or politically to call for for ANYONE to be terminated from their place of employment. It’s both amusing and disturbing how the professed “tolerant” have become the most intolerant of all.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Self-entitled College kids who have never worked a day in their life are in no position, personally or politically to call for for ANYONE to be terminated from their place of employment. It’s both amusing and disturbing how the professed “tolerant” have become the most intolerant of all.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s