Jennifer Leidig has [correction] resigned completed her term on the Saratoga Springs Civil Service Commission, leaving a vacancy. The Commission has three members. No two can be affiliated with the same political party according to the city charter . Currently one is a Democrat ( Joanna Zangrando), one is a Republican (Tim Holmes), and one is a registered voter with no party affiliation (Ms. Leidig) The Commissioners serve six year staggered terms.
While usually it has been the Mayor who nominates individuals to fill vacancies on this Commission, the City Charter gives the Council the authority to vote to appoint the members.
This time Mayor John Safford has put forward Vince DeLeonardis’s name, but Accounts Commissioner Dillon Moran is supporting Jeff Altamari to fill Ms. Leidig’s position. Both candidates are registered voters with no party affiliation so both are technically able to be appointed to the Commission. Mr. Altamari, however, has a very partisan history of supporting the local Democrats and has no experience with municipal employment issues. In contrast Mr. DeLeonardis has stayed clear of partisan politics and as former City Attorney from 2014 to 2022 has extensive knowledge of city civil service issues.
The Saratoga Springs Civil Service Commission is responsible for adopting and modifying local civil service rules, classifying positions and adopting job descriptions, administering the civil service examination process, overseeing and authorizing all employment transactions, and maintaining the official employment records for all employees of the City of Saratoga Springs, the Saratoga Springs Central School District, the Saratoga Springs Public Library, the City Center and the Housing Authority. Readers will remember that controversial issues like whether the Risk and Safety Director should have been under the direction of Accounts Commissioner Dillon Moran or Mayor Ron Kim were decided ultimately by the city’s Civil Service Commission.
A Titular Independent
The following are the donations made by Mr. Altamari since July 2020. As is clear, Mr. Altamari’s donations are all to Democrats.
In addition to making donations, Mr. Altamari has served as the treasurer for Joanne Yepsen (D), Meg Kelly (D), and Gordon Boyd (D). He may have served other candidates but these are the three I was able to find. Again, the only candidates he has served as treasurer are all Democrats.
This is a picture of Mr. Altamari at a Democratic Fundraiser from 2017. Mr. Altamari is on the left.
Mr. Altamari had a successful career as an executive with an oil company in Texas and has retired to Saratoga Springs.
While technically, Mr. Altamari is eligible for the independent seat on the Civil Service Commission, his records indicate a strong identification with the Democratic Party.
In October 2017, I posted about an intemperate and inaccurate letter to the editor Mr. Altamari wrote attacking then Accounts Commissioner John Franck. Readers might take the time to watch the video associated with his letter and decide for themselves whether my characterization of it was appropriate.
A Real Independent
Like Mr. Altamari, Vince DeLeonardis is an unaffiliated registered voter. Unlike Mr. Altamari, though, Mr. DeLeonardis has not made a contribution to either the Democrats or the Republicans. His only contribution was to the One Saratoga Party. Readers may remember that this party endorsed both Democrats and Republicans, which, to my mind, epitomizes who would be best suited to act as an independent on the Commission.
More importantly, Mr DeLeonardis served as the City Attorney from October ,2014, until he was unceremoniously dismissed by Mayor Kim in January, 2022. During his tenure, he worked collegially and effectively with the elected officials of both parties on the Council. He established a record of fairness and thoroughness. Clearly, his long tenure as City Attorney means that he would have a much greater understanding of our city government’s staffing than Mr. Altamari who’s only experience was in the private sector.
To this blogger, there is no comparison between the qualifications of Mr. DeLeonardis and Mr. Altamari.
Golub Yet Again The Swing Vote
It is my understanding that Mayor Safford approached Public Works Commissioner Jason Golub to inquire which of the two men he intended to vote for. Golub told him he was supporting Altamari. As Finance Commissioner Minita Sanghvi has reliably supported every resolution brought forward by Commissioner Moran, so Golub’s vote guarantees that Altamari will be the next appointed member of the Civil Service Commission.
I texted Commissioner Golub, asking him why he was supporting Altamari over DeLeonardis. He never responded.
This is all very disappointing. DeLeonardis was an extraordinary City Attorney who would have provided an invaluable voice on the Commission.
Saratoga Springs Politics 
Jeff Altamari is a nice man who has been closely associated with certain local Democratic candidates.
Vince DeLeonardis was an extraordinary City attorney who ignored political labels and cliques as he served so well in that role. Ron Kim made a big mistake when he failed to re-appoint him. Vince would be the best choice for the Civil Service Commission.
Chris Mathiesen
LikeLiked by 1 person
While I’m sure you’re correct that Mr. DeLeonardis is a qualified, or even the most qualified candidate, don’t you think it’s more than a little disingenuous to characterize Mr. Altamari’s contributions to Tim Coll as partisan-Democrat as he was the endorsed candidate of the SS GOP, and was running against the (two different) SS Dem endorsed candidates? The reality of Tim Coll’s candidacy doesn’t fit your desired thesis.
LikeLike
Point taken
LikeLike
Bruce, you could take the donations out of the equation all together and just focus on the Democrat political campaigns spanning decades in which Mr. Altamari has played a key role in, most recently as treasurer for Gordon Boyd. This information alone is enough to show Mr. Altamari is not the right candidate for a nonpartisan Civil Service Commissioner role. City Council is fortunate enough to have another option of a truly nonpartisan candidate, Mr. Deleonardis.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Take a look at the video of the preliminary council meeting where Commissioner Moran brings up the vote for the position. The exchange with the Mayor is classic dillon.
LikeLiked by 1 person
What is the date of that pre council meeting? Thanks.
LikeLike
I agree. The video is priceless. Dillon has no interest in looking at the facts. He just wants it his way or the highway. Petty at its best.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I have been a Republican Committee person since 1995. I have never seen Mr. Altamari associate with any of the Republican party in the years that I have been involved. At one point Skip was the only Republican Commissioner in City Hall and Vince treated him the same as anyone else. And he knows the Charter.
LikeLiked by 1 person
This is just another character test for Commissioner Golub. Any educated person can see the problem here. We know who Dillon will vote for. Commissioner Sanghvi is regularly seen campaigning with Michelle Ostelich, to whom Altamari donated several times. Golub also received a sizable donation from Altamari. The three of them seem fine taking care of the man behind the checkbook that supports registered Democrats.
Tim Coll did receive generous donations from Altamari. Commissioner Coll could vote yes placing his generous benefactor on the Civil Service Commission. Based on factual known biased toward one party it would be very irresponsible for Coll to vote for Altamari. Commissioner Coll, I imagine will choose the most nonpartisan candidate, Deleonardis.
Political appointments aren’t supposed to based campaign donations. This one should not be based on political affiliation either. Altamari could set up a double whammy here. One can still appreciate a generous donor. A generous donor can also appreciate nothing in return,
Commissioner Moran you have no legs to stand on in arguing that your choice will balance out the political dynamics the Civil Service Commission. Maybe Mr. Altamari will take himself out of the running to save political face. Judgement day is here. Will the Honorable Commissioner Jason Golub Esq. make the honorable decision or vote in a political pact?
LikeLiked by 2 people
Your answer is in your question.
LikeLike
I think the focus should be on our Rogue Dillon Moran instead of worrying about the two candidates who want to serve on the Civil Service Commission. I’m sure both men have good intentions, and each would only have one vote. But Moran seems to be the most outspoken of the members of our City Council, and his manner of speaking to other council members is abhorrent. I’ve also seen the way he treats the public. Mr Kaufmann was the victim at a recent public comment period.
Commissioner Golub seems to be an intelligent man, but his silence at meetings is a big disappointment. He is lucky to have a dedicated Deputy Commissioner. Golub’s parking plan will go by the wayside when he is replaced. If it ain’t broke why try to fix it?
LikeLiked by 2 people