An Ivins Press Release and a Madigan Response

I received a press release from Ken Ivins, who is running for Commissioner of Finance.  In his release he accuses Commissioner Madigan of receiving money from a lobbying firm that represents Saratoga National Golf Course.  I contacted him and asked if he could provide documentation for this and he indicated that, regrettably, he was unable to.

In fairness to his opponent, Commissioner Michele Madigan, I sent her the press release and asked if she wanted to respond.  She did and below are the press release and Commissioner Madigan’s response.

Ivins Declines to Meet with Saratoga PAC

“My vote is not for sale.”

For immediate release


 Ken Ivins Candidate for the position of Commissioner of Finance was invited to interview with the Saratoga PAC on Friday October 16th. He declined that invitation. His opponent Michelle Madigan not only agreed to meet with them , but invited them to City Hall for the meeting.

In an email sent to Bob Manz Chairman of the Saratoga PAC, Ken wrote:


Thank you for the opportunity of meeting with the newly formed Saratoga PAC. After much reflection I have come to the conclusion that at this time I respectfully decline your invitation to be interviewed. While I appreciate the invitation, I am not seeking your endorsement and therefore don’t wish to waste your time.

Your group has conducted itself professionally and I have much respect for many of the individuals who comprise your Board. However, as I go door to door many citizens have expressed concerns about political influences from big money and special interest groups. Because your group has just recently emerged and thus has no track record, the community is very nervous.

As I have said from the beginning, because I am not endorsed by my local Party, I am running as an independent candidate, beholden to no one except the voters. I understand that leaves me at a disadvantage, especially financially, but I truly believe the position of Commissioner of Finance needs to be free from any perceptions of impropriety.

If I win the election, then I would be happy to sit down with any members of the Saratoga PAC and discuss the important issues of the city. Meanwhile, I would like to congratulate you all regarding the city-wide survey you conducted and I look forward to hearing the results.

Again thank you for inviting me and I hope to be talking with you in the future,

Ken Ivins

The current Commissioner has accepted over $500 from a lobbying firm representing Saratoga National Golf Course, received money and the endorsements from the City Fire Fighters union and the Saratoga Police Benevolent Association (groups whose contracts she would be voting on if re-elected), over $700 total from the director and members of the City Center Authority, (Madigan has still not released the emails she redacted between she and the Director of the City Center regarding the parking garage and her true role she has played in that process) and now she will meet with the Saratoga PAC. “It makes you wonder who she serves, special interest groups or the tax payers,” states Ken Ivins.

Ken goes on to say, “I will only represent the voters of this city, not the party bosses or a special interest group. My vote is not for sale.” 

Ken will having a press conference on Thursday, October 15th at 4:00pm at High Rock Parking lot to discuss this issue as well as the Comprehensive Budget presented by the current Commissioner and how it is designed intentionally with flaws to fool the public into voting for her.

Madigan Replies:

Dear members of the media:

I received the following press release last night and can only hope you will be contacting me to discuss all the lies and made up nonsense Mr. Ivins seems to be desperately peddling about me these days. This from a man who has lost his last 2 elections and could not obtain a 2nd on a motion for endorsement by his Republican Party to run again for finance commissioner.

What he writes about the PAC is not true. I declined to be interviewed by the Super PAC for an endorsement meeting at the holiday inn. I simply didn’t think this news required a headline / press release. I did tell them, and tell all my constituents, I’m available to meet as their elected commissioner of finance at city hall to listen to their issues and concerns. As I would any citizen.  The PAC has declined my offer to meet with me as constituents.

He lies regularly and doesn’t have the facts.  The attack he proposes on Thursday against my budget shows once again the man does not understand city finances. When this man was I charge of our city’s finances he would regularly tell the public he was “bamboozled” by his fellow council members and that if he didn’t know something he would simply “make it up”.

The PBA did not endorse me this time around because I did not support their contract. I’m watching out for the taxpayers. They have endorsed the Mayor and Commissioner Franck, both of whom voted in the affirmative for the PBA Contract.  The firefighters have never given me money. Some group gave me $250 – northeast government consulting – they give to everyone. The Mayor and various commissioners and have been donating since my first campaign. etc. They have never requested a meeting with me to discuss my positions on any issue.   I’m proud of my association with the city center and those constituents that represent me for a broad base of reasons. My vote is never and has never been for sale!!  My constituents know this.

As for my opponent, this is a man who raised taxes by over 12%, laid off 49 city employees, and found himself with millions in surplus at the end of each year of his years a Finance Commissioner.  There was no reason to ever lay off a single city employee. There is so much more I can say about his very poor budgeting technique on behalf of the taxpayers of this city.

Respectfully, Michele Madigan

4 thoughts on “An Ivins Press Release and a Madigan Response”

  1. This gets even better John. Ken Ivins changed his press release on his Facebook page (I have both copies), and when I went to comment he locked down his Facebook page so no one else could comment.

    But get this: he wrote to the Saratoga PAC:

    “If I win the election, then I would be happy to sit down with any members of the Saratoga PAC and discuss the important issues of the city. Meanwhile, I would like to congratulate you all regarding the city-wide survey you conducted and I look forward to hearing the results.”

    Yet in one of the versions (the original I believe) of his “press release” he wrote this:

    “His opponent Michelle Madigan not only agreed to meet with them, but invited them to City Hall for the meeting.”

    Now, is that not the same exact thing he is blasting Michele for? Yet, Michele did NOT interview with the Saratoga PAC, nor did she meet with them, because THEY refused to meet with her as any other citizen or group would have to.

    How anyone can even think to vote for Ivins astounds me truthfully. He did an absolutely brutal job as Finance commish – so bad that even his own party doesn’t want him – and is now caught lying on the public record. On the other hand, Michele has restored fiscal responsibility to our local government (she has regained our AA+ rating that was lost under Ivins) and our books – and future – are in perfect order.

    This isn’t even a case of voting republican/democrat or conservative/liberal. It’s a matter of voting for sanity at this point.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. Well, Commissioner Madigan used to be my hero(ine) but I have to admit I have been angered and dismayed watching her tortured attempts to help SNGC get their resort in the greenbelt. And now this rant from her. Not very professional. I note too she does not deny that Northeast Government Consulting has ties to SNGC. While she states “they give to everyone” I doubt if “everyone”includes Scirocco and Mathiesen.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I would call this a ‘Mulligan for Madigan’. One can only be lied about so many times before they blow off a little bit of steam. And lies they truly are. I also think people are not understanding her position on SNGC truthfully. If she was ‘torturing herself’ to help the golf course she would have already voted for it, and it would have already been a done deal – but she did NOT. As for NGC, it has ‘ties’ with a LOT of different people and businesses. That’s always been a very far-fetched claim without any proof attached to it whatsoever.

      But if this is Michele at her worst? I’ll take it and her over Ken Ivin’s at his best ANY day of the year. We’ve already seen him in action, and it cost the taxpayers – and 49 city employees – dearly. He really was so bad his own party wouldn’t even consider him again. This one isn’t even close.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s